Tesla Model 3 vs BMW i4 – Which is Better?
Red Tesla
With Tesla going head to head against mainstream manufacturers, the Tesla Model 3 vs. BMW i4 rivalry is one of the most thrilling battles that has been taking place in the EV market. Both these electric sedans bring along top-shelf technology, strong performance, and premium features, but which one is a better fit for you?
With this buying guide, we put the Tesla Model 3 and BMW i4 head to head in key areas: performance, range, interior quality, technology and overall value.
Performance and Drive
Tesla Model 3
Engine Variants: RWD, Long Range AWD, Performance
0-60 mph in as little as 3.1 seconds (Performance model)
Handling: Light and responsive with a minimalist feel
Driving Dynamics: Instant torque and silky-smooth acceleration
The Tesla Model 3 is considered to be well-known for instant acceleration, smooth handling, and direct steering. In fact, the Performance model has very sports-carlike acceleration, besting some higher-performance gasoline rivals. However, the Model 3 leans more toward efficiency than driving excitement, which makes it a bit less engaging than the traditional sports sedans.
BMW i4
Powertrain options: eDrive35, eDrive40 (RWD), and M50 (AWD)
0-60 mph time: As quick as 3.7 seconds (M50 model)
Handling: Sporty and dynamic, with a weightier steering feel
Driving Dynamics: Classic BMW driving experience with EV power
Some of BMW's legendary driving dynamics are found in the way the BMW i4 handles with real precision. The BMW always felt planted on the road. There's little question that, for driving enthusiasts, the i4 M50-its dual-motor setup providing extra shove-is going to be a real thrill.
Winner: BMW i4 – More involving to drive, especially in the M50.
Grey BMW i4
Range and Charging
Tesla Model 3
Up to 391 miles for Long Range, WLTP
Available Tesla's Supercharger network - fast charging where it's accepted
Most competitive miles per kWh in the business
Tesla's advantage is in charging infrastructure. The Model 3 has access to the Supercharger network for faster, more convenient charging than most non-Tesla EVs, plus it's highly efficient, yielding more range per charge.
BMW i4
Range: Up to 365 miles (eDrive40 model, WLTP)
Charging: 200 kW DC fast charging, capable of adding 102 miles in 10 minutes
Efficiency: Slightly lower than Model 3 and competitive
Yes, the i4 offers huge range and incredible fast-charging capability, which is somewhat softened by the vehicle's inability to tap into the Tesla Supercharger network, surely one of its biggest advantages.
Winner: Tesla Model 3 – Tesla has longer reach and better Infrastructure.
Interior of A Tesla
Interior and Comfort
Tesla Model 3
Minimalist interior with one central touchscreen taking care of virtually all controls
Premium materials-lacks traditional tactility of the luxury
Spacious seating with a glass roof for an airy cabin
Tesla's interior is sleek and futuristic, with a clean design dominated by a large touchscreen. However, some drivers may find the lack of physical controls frustrating, and the material quality, while good, doesn't quite match traditional luxury standards.
BMW i4
Classic BMW luxury with premium materials and build quality
Curved digital display with physical buttons for essential functions
Comfort: Supportive seats, great sound insulation
The BMW i4 has a rather more conventionally conceived interior: nicer materials and a better laid-out cockpit. There's also a big curved digital display, although this integrates modern tech within an arguably more comfortable, normal driving environment.
Winner: BMW i4 – feels more upscale and is more ergonomic
Rear View of BMW i4
Technology and Infotainment
Tesla Model 3
15-inch centre screen with Tesla's bespoke user interface
OTA software updates
Package available: Autopilot and Full Self-Driving
Tesla's infotainment system is among the most sophisticated on the market, with real-time updates to navigation, streaming capability, and voice control. Over-the-air updates further hone the functionality of the car, often introducing new features over time.
BMW i4
iDrive 8 infotainment system with a curved digital display
Apple CarPlay and Android Auto integration
Advanced driver assistance features, but no full self-driving equivalent
BMW's iDrive system is intuitive and responsive, with physical controls sitting alongside touchscreen functions. It doesn't boast the same level of updates as Tesla's tech, but it's still an excellent all-rounder.
Winner: Tesla Model 3 – More advanced software and future-proof updates.
Silver Livery Tesla
Price and Value
Tesla Model 3
Starting price: Around £42,000
Performance Model price: Around £59,000
Lower running costs due to high efficiency
Tesla Model 3 pricing is competitive for the range it offers, especially with advanced tech onboard. Its lower running costs and the chance to charge from free or at least inexpensive Supercharger stations also make it cheaper overall.
BMW i4
Starting price: Around £50,000
M50 Model price: Around £70,000
Stronger residuals because of premium branding with BMW
Admittedly, the BMW i4 is more expensive than the Model 3, but it has better interior quality and is much more fun to drive. On the other hand, Tesla's more affordable price and overall lower running costs make it more attractive to a budget-conscious buyer.
Winner: Tesla Model 3 – Most affordable and most cost-efficient long-term.
Parked White Tesla
Final Verdict – Which is Better?
BMW Car Charging
The Tesla Model 3 and BMW i4 each have their high points, and both are superb choices depending on your preference.
Go for the Tesla Model 3 if you want the best range, access to Tesla's charging network, the most advanced tech, and the lowest long-term costs.
If you want a more sumptuous interior, a traditional driving experience, and a well-judged blend of performance and comfort, the BMW i4 is the better choice.
Ultimately, if range, technology, and value are your top priorities, then the Tesla Model 3 is the better choice. If, however, you're in the market for a premium electric sedan with dynamic driving and high-end craftsmanship, the BMW i4 is the way to go.
Want the best deal on the Tesla Model 3 or BMW i4? Explore available offers and find your perfect electric sedan today.
